All Star Pizza, Rochester, New York Restaurant Details

Food:

Best pizza by far that I've found in the area. I moved here months ago and have tried many different pizza places, this is the one place I will go back to again and again. Prices are a little high but we'll worth it.

Food:

I have always enjoyed All Star Pizza. However, my last order was an hour late. I called and the owner nicely told me they are slammed. I certainly understood and my order arrived shortly after I hung up. However, the issue that concerns me most is the pizza was down right cold. I always look forward to a hot pie from All Star and was disappointed with the order I received. I will give them another try but if I get another cold pizza, I may have to move on.

Food:

Had high expectations based on previous reviews. Mediocre tasting pizzas and overpriced. Was also over charged by a few bucks.

I've tasted better pizza at Domino's

Food:

I live right up the street from All-star and it took me 5 years (and the fact I was running late) to work up the courage to try it and I'll never order from another pizza place. The food has always been great, and I love all the different kinds of pizza they have. Only had one problem when a new driver couldn't find my apartment but it was all worked out within 5 minutes. My favorite place to order from.

Food:

I ordered pizza and wings and they were great. They were super friendly and the pizza is the best ive had. If you don't like thin new york style you'd better specify otherwise its thin. Great wings. Thanks