Athenian Greek Taverna, Commack, New York, Greek Restaurant Details

Food:

The BEST greek food ever! Alex is awesome and very accommodating. We catered another birthday party at my house today from them. Once again, everyone raved about how great all of the food was. The staff is very patient and creative with us to create an order that everyone will enjoy. A ton of food for a great price. Having an event catered by Athenia takes all the stress away from planning your special day. I highly recommend you think about them for your next event!!

Food:

best greek food in town!!! highly recommended! !!!

Food:

In my opinion, this is THE Greek restaurant to go to in Suffolk County. The generous portions, authentic taste, and a home-like warm atmosphere are something I always look forward to. The yogurt sauce and salad dressing are well known and delicious. It is very reasonably priced considering the quality of REAL Greek food you get at Athenian. The staff makes you feel like part of the family and are very genuine. 5 stars.

Food:

The service, atmosphere and the food was delicious. The chicken orzo soup was very rich, plenty of chicken and very 'homely'. The pita bread was very fresh.

I only have a couple of gripes:

The gyro melt was a bit disappointing. It is just meat and melted cheese on pita bread with tzatziki sauce on the side, there is no lettuce, tomato or other toppings. Meat was a bit overcooked.

The tzatziki sauce has WAY too much garlic to the point of being overpowering, leaving too strong of an aftertaste. My body/breath smelled like garlic well into the next day, even after several teeth brushings/mouthwashes.

I don't mind giving them another try. The price and portion are very fair, it is a very nice and clean place, and the service was fine. I will probably order a more 'meaty' gyro and hopefully the tzatziki sauce was just a fluke. Please ease up on the garlic!

Food:

Best taste I have had outside of Greek town in Toronto, Canada! I have traveled to many places in US and this is the most authentic and tasty. Ordered take out twice; it was fast, clean and no nonsense! Portions are generous and affordable. Great family food! Best dish for me was the Greek salad with Chicken! Yum!