Atlantic Street Pizza Slices, Seattle, Washington, Pizza Restaurant Details

Food:

Dude, I took one bite of the Atlantic Special, and now I'm sad that I'm not from Washington and that this place doesn't exist where I'm from. Hands down best freaking pizza I've had. Worth every penny. I got the lunch special #2 with a salad and soda, and the salad is quite sizeable, as is the pizza slice. I'm trying really hard not to scarf this pizza right now because it's so freaking good, I want to savor it.

It's a small joint, and the guy working the counter is straight up Italian and tells it like it is. I got my food fast and the pizza was hot, salad fresh, and I am one happy camper. I'd come back to Seattle just to have this pizza again.

Food:

If you are expecting the same Atlantic Street Pizza from over 10 years ago, this isn't that place. I got my usual when I was living in the U-District and went here a lot. Which was the Atlantic Street Special. It was thin on toppings, WTF? This is not the same pie, sauce was different as well, crust was bland, like they forgot to put something in it, very yeasty. Very sad how this place has gone down hill since the new owners.

Food:

Not the *worst* slice of pizza I've ever eaten, but bloody close to it. Despite reviews that say the crust is thin, it is EXTREMELY thick and doughy. Also bland, with a sugary, cloyingly sweet sauce, and a layer of rubber that passes for cheese. I couldn't finish even a single slice of tomato basil.

Food:

I came online to look at the reviews of this place, and my mind was blown. Simply for the fact that this pizza was the worst pizza I have ever eaten. I didn't actually go in and eat here or get served by the people who work there, so I can't speak to that. This pizza was brought into work, and although it was a very nice gesture, I could not even consume 1 whole slice. The crust lacked any flavor whatsoever. Is there even salt in it? Anything? The sauce was much too sweet. The cheese topping was ok, but I couldn't get past the sauce/crust debacle, and at that point it wasn't even pizza to me. Nor was it worth eating.

I like to give this quaint, local place the benefit of the doubt, since it has some good reviews. Maybe since it was a large order for a big company some steps got missed in the baking process? Maybe the usual care wasn't given to this large order? I can't say for sure. But with out exaggeration, based on this one experience, It was the worst pizza I ever ate.

Food:

i've only been twice, it was a little hard to find and most of the stores around it were closed. i was worried thinking they had gone under until i went down another level, and there they are tucked right underneath an escalator as mentioned. it's on the SW corner facing 2nd.

The sauce is fantastic, the dough is so good, and the toppings are amazing. i snagged a salad today and it was HUGE, 2nd half will be had for dinner. their website says a drink+slice+salad is $7. in-store he said the salad+pizza is $7, then $0.50 for the drink.

the salad is lettuce, mushroom, tomato, black olives, bell pepper, croutons, and i think it was parmesan cheese. if it had onions it'd be perfect.

it's so good i plan on ordering full size pies then exist for the next 3 days on nothing but this wonderful stuff.

very friendly staff as well, support these guys!