Bagels By The Bay, Staten Island, New York, Bagels Restaurant Details

Food:

I order pancakes thinking its fresh and come to find out its Microwavable and I ask for egg whites and its always yellow and burnt.

Food:

Best bagels!

Food:

Bagels By the Bay have the biggest bagels you have ever seen. Heavier than a hockey puck and big like a cloud, they’re a bagel lover’s dream. I like to get plain or with sesame. If you get an everything bagel, get it in a separate bag because the onion flavoring is so overwhelming. Plus the everything bagel is very salty. But they deliver a quality product and everything is fresh daily. Get there early before your favorite bagels sell out.

Food:

The bagels are baked fresh in the morning. Good way to enjoy with just simple spread or pile some eggs and breakfast meat on it. There are also a number of sandwich that would suit anyone's fancy. I like the special that has both chicken and eggplant cutlets with fresh mozzarella. Massive and amazing.

Food:

This place is run by brothers who know what they are doing.

I am not originally from the area, and I get visitors regularly from out of state. Once I have taken them to Bagels by the Bay... my friends ASK to go back!!!