Bexley Pizza Plus, Columbus, Ohio, Italian Restaurant Details

Food:

Pizza is OK nothing special in my opinion. It is a popular spot with the locals though and the service is pretty good.

Food:

Yummy pizza with lots of great options.

Food:

Perfect everything everytime

Food:

I love Bexley Pizza Plus their veggie pizza is the BEST. I was a Pizza Hut all the way person untiI I eat here. The prices are great and the pizzas are super fabulous.

Food:

me·di·o·cre
adjective
of only moderate quality; not very good.

We have walked past Bexley Pizza Plus on numerous occasions and marveled at the smells wafting through the streets but we'd never actually sat down and tried it. After hearing about their International Award for their pizza, we thought it was high time that we try it.

There must be something in the water there in Bexley that makes you rate this a five star pizza joint, but I'd definitely recommend heading down to Anthony's or over to Padova's or heck, CiCi's has better pizza.

With lackluster service, generic pre-packaged ingredients, and dull and gummy crust I whole heartedly expected an epic pizza. What I got was mediocre.

If you define yourself as a pizza connoisseur I would steer clear of this pizza. And here I thought The Spaghetti Warehouse was the worst food I'd ever had.

I've had better from the frozen section. ... and FOUR DOLLARS AND EIGHTY FIVE CENTS for a slice of Cheesecake? You are not The Cheesecake Factory.

This is a definite fail, in my most humble opinion.