Castleton Grill, Indianapolis, Indiana Restaurant Details

Food:

The waitress was not friendly. The fish and chips were not very good. The kids meals were cheaply made and not worth the money.

Food:

Horrible!!! I was looking for some place for a good steak in Indianapolis. This was definitely not the place. Worst steak I've ever had in my life. Could not cut through the Prime Rib, that tasted like a cheap roast. Could not get my fork into the vegetables. Good service, but the worst food I've ever had at a restaurant.

Food:

Been going here 15 years and I just want to say if you had an unfortunate experience, give it a go once more. It may have been an off night. We got here A LOT and sometimes it gets so busy it is unreal and your wait can last a bit but our food is always great and service is fantastic. For every crappy waitress I've had, there is about a dozen others who are amazing. And I notice the bad ones don't stay long, either. Mary,Tim, Eva, Becky, Julie, all great people and staff. Cheese tries are to die for.

Food:

Service was nice. I really wanted the food to be better. :( I could hardly cut through the brussel sprouts, let alone eat them. The steamed broccoli was also undercooked. Salmon was good though! Yaaaay salmon!

Food:

We've been eating here for years. Yes, there was a brief time period where the service declined, but the last several times we have been back (since the renovation) the service has been back to it's high standards. The food here is great, with a nice wide selection to choose from. Good beers are a plus. If you go after 7pm or so there is no waiting - they seem to have mostly an early dinner crowd.The prices are reasonable, and we will continue to enjoy this restaurant which is so much nicer and more cozy than a chain eatery.