Jaymie's Pizza, Manorville, New York, Pizza Restaurant Details

Food:

My family has been a loyal customer week after week. For the first time, I decided to add 2 2-liters to the order. I expect an increase in cost, but $3.75 per bottle? I ordered a Sicilian pie with just cheese that looks like vomit. It was made like crap (very doughy in the center...burnt hard on the edges) that it didn't even fit in the box, so the employee just smushed the box closed. The second pie was a Round pie with pepperoni. The pepperoni were under-cooked. The cheese was melted well. The dough was very thin towards the center to where the slice flopped and everything slid off on the plate. Our usual order of a dozen garlic knots with extra garlic was the only item that was prepared the way we normally get it. Sadly, though, the pizza is the main course and based on its preparation, I will not order from Jamie's again.

Food:

Worst Pizza ever..They claim it was fresh and that was a lie..extra sauce half meatball...you can see it was thrown on top of an old pie....had to throw it away....sauce must be canned..gross..was starving and after one slice i havent been able to eat for hours..all appetites been lost...store seemed uninterested in replacing it...you cant get a good pizza anywhere out east...i give up

Food:

Food. Always great

Food:

Good pizza... I had done bad experiences trying to find good pizza anywhere close enough to my house to be able to bring it home and still have it be hot... This one wasn't one of the bad experiences...

Food:

Amazing food! The place looks a little run down. But that'd where the best pizza is.. I buy a majority of chicken rolls. But they only come fromthe here!
1 problem: cash only.