Jeremiah's Tavern, Rochester, New York, Seafood Restaurant Details

Food:

Best wings? Don't think so. The garlic parm wings were awful. They were essentially fried wings sitting in nasty oil, with a little bit of parmesan on top of half of them. The hot wings were decent but nothing different than any hot wing you've had before.

The loaded fries were bland. The cheese was not warm, and the bacon was bland. It tasted like someone threw cheese and bacon bits on frozen french fries and put that in the oven for a few minutes. The worst thing was the cornbread. I can't remember the last time I had food that bad at a restaurant. The texture was off and the flavor was offensive.

To top it off, the service was terrible. Our waitress was handling at least 10 tables at once and it took a very long time to place our order and get the bill.

I will never come back to Jeremiah's.

Food:

They could use more staff and better train them because being in a restaurant for a total of 3 and half hours for a party of 15 is just waay too long. But other than that, beer selection was great and their signature wings were well worth the wait. I tried a total of six flavors and they were all good!

Food:

Over Labor Day weekend I visited the newest location in Penfield. The outdoor bar seemed nice, except the view is just medicore. However, the nightmare came two days later as I looked at my bank statement. One of the outdoor bartenders charged some other patron's tab on my card! It was a large amount, too. I am hoping the management will be able to rectify the situation without having to dispute the charge with my bank (the bank suggested I contact the vendor first). Not a great first impression. :-(

Food:

I've been here several times over the past three years--including a few times in the past few weeks to watch World Cup games--and can agree with many of the other negative reviews here: the place has gone downhill. The food is mediocre, over-salted, and waaaaaayyy too expensive for what it is. The service is poor. And to top it all off, the past few times I've been in there my beer tasted bad, flat, and like it came from tap lines that hadn't been cleaned in far too long. I'll not be back anytime soon.

Food:

I've lived in the neighborhood for over 5 years and I'm sad to say that no matter how much I've tried to love this place, it's never loved me back. Food is good, wait staff is good, but the bar side is just terrible. 20 minutes for service or even eye contact is just too long (on most occasions). I've tried speaking with a manager, but they seem to encourage the lazy behavior. I'm sad to be moving out of the neighborhood, but I'm looking forward to finding a better bar.