Carthage from Indiana Please Register or Login to add your Restaurant Not Listed? Add your Restaurant! On Map Gus's Cafe - Indiana, Carthage, 8 East Mill Street, 46115 (765) 565-9903 Map Jones Cafe & Lounge - Indiana, Carthage, 2 S Main St, 46115 (765) 565-6259 Map Pit Stop Pizza & Pub - Indiana, Carthage, 711 N Main St, 46115 Pizza (765) 565-6078 Map