Cattaraugus from New York Please Register or Login to add your Restaurant Not Listed? Add your Restaurant! On Map 25 Slice - New York, Cattaraugus, 9119 East Otto Road, 14719 (716) 257-5423 Map Cattaraugus Deli - New York, Cattaraugus, 19 Main Street, 14719 (716) 257-3332 Map Pascarella's Restaurant - New York, Cattaraugus, 12 Washington St, 14719 Family Style (716) 257-3394 Map