New Middletown from Ohio Please Register or Login to add your Restaurant Not Listed? Add your Restaurant! On Map Baker Square Bakery - Ohio, New Middletown, 13 Sycamore Dr, 44442 (330) 542-2592 Map Bravo's Pizza & Subs - Ohio, New Middletown, 9864 Youngstown Pittsburg, 44442 (330) 542-9552 Map Dairy Queen - Ohio, New Middletown, 10201 Main St, 44442 Fast Food (330) 542-2362 Map De Chellis Italian Cafe - Ohio, New Middletown, 11092 Main St, 44442 (330) 542-3733 Map Subway - Ohio, New Middletown, 10651 Main St, 44442 Delicatessen (330) 542-2910 Map Subway Sandwiches & Salads - Ohio, New Middletown, Po Box 95, 44442 Map