West Islip from New York Please Register or Login to add your Restaurant Not Listed? Add your Restaurant! On Map Subway Sandwiches & Salads - New York, West Islip, 282 Higbie Ln # C, 11795 Map Victorio Ii Pizza - New York, West Islip, 20 Bay Shore Rd, 11795 Pizza (631) 586-5552 Map Villa Monaco - New York, West Islip, 778 Montauk Hwy, 11795 (631) 661-5599 Map Villa Monaco Restaurant - New York, West Islip, 778 Montauk Highway, 11795 (877) 492-1229 Map West Islip Bagel - New York, West Islip, 544 Hunter Ave, 11795 (631) 321-1769 Map Ziegler Delicatessen - New York, West Islip, 17 Udall Rd, 11795 (631) 661-9115 Map « Previous 12