Stella's Pizza, Jersey City, New Jersey, Italian Restaurant Details

Food:

Utterly tasteless pizza. I get that I wasn't in Manhattan, but this was really disappointing.

Food:

Two out of the three times that I've ordered from them, they've forgotten parts of the order. When I called to ask about it, the guy on the phone argues with me that I never ordered the items in question (the receipt accompanying the order states otherwise) and that I shouldn't get them anyway because the price was wrong online (not my fault they don't update their menus).

Such nonsense over subpar food. If they'll cheat you out of $3, imagine on what else they'll cheat.

Food:

Been eating here my whole life and its the best pizza I've ever had. Hands down.

Food:

Good pizza & good prices. Definitely my favorite place to stop by when in Jersey City.

Food:

I ordered Cheese fries and a pizza steak and what was..

For the cheese fries, they apparently came from Shoprite in a big plastic bag locked in place with a cast of harden government cheese.

The pizza steak was basically a roll with a fresh jar of Ragu sauce poured over chucks of evenly chopped up steak and a load of mozzarella cheese. To make such a meal even worse, the bread appeared to be soggy from the sauce.

If you're going to order from this place, save yourself time and money and have a friend who can't cook create their own version of it. I'm sure it'll taste better.

Sad part was, they refused to send the order that came to $14.50 since the minimum order amount is $15.00.