Food:

"Fresh-off-the-boat seafood" – from fish 'n' chips to "all the oyster varieties you could ever want" – lures diners to this moderately priced Murray Hill "fish market with counter seating and a few tables"; despite the "cramped quarters" and sometimes "slow" service, fans applaud the "feeling of integrity about the place."

Food:

Great fish restaurant!! One of the best in the city (if you're looking for high end food, not atmosphere). The food is always as fresh as can be, cooked very simple but very very good (with fresh fish you dont need too much)

Food:

The oysters here are $1 all day every day and they are fresher than any oysters I've had in the city. The staff is incredible, the beer on tap is always amazing, and the fish tacos best I've ever had. That's coming from a Texan. Don't listen to bozos on here who are giving it 3 stars because they don't like seafood. This place is incredible and deserves 5 stars.

Food:

I'm probably biased since I'm not a crazy seafood fan (my friends wants to come here and I thought I wanted some change in my life...ahha) but I have had better oysters elsewhere. Although they were fresh, I was probably really distracted by the massive amounts of shell bits all over the actual fleshy part of it.
Big disappointment in shucking abilities ..being that it's a seafood place and that's their specialty.
Don't think I will come back, meh. Everything else is so crazy overpriced. I tried a bit of the Lobster Mac and Cheese but it had such a huge ocean taste to it and not very much cheese taste. blegh. no.
yeah i'm biased..
BUT THE SHELL BITS!!!!!!! NO!!!!!!!

Food:

One of the best fish restaurants I've been to. Feels like a no frills market, with fresh fish cooked to order. Great oysters and the creamy chowder seemed v popular.

Food:

An almost "hole in the wall" place that does the best fish in New York City at a reasonable price.

Fantastic oysters, great tuna or any seafood dish you might like in a simple decor, and some great beers to choose from as well.

Warning for non-fish eaters, you may go hungry as this is a dedicated establishment.